Singing Carrots vs Singing Simplified on Udemy: Which Is Better for Beginners?

Choosing between Singing Carrots and SINGING SIMPLIFIED #1: The Fast-Track to Singing Like a Pro comes down to what you need most in your vocal training. In this SINGING SIMPLIFIED review, we’ll compare its structured Udemy lessons with Singing Carrots’ interactive tools and feedback-driven platform—so you can decide which approach matches your goals.

Singing Simplified #1 on Udemy – Overview

Singing Simplified #1 is one of the most popular singing courses on Udemy, taught through pre-recorded video lessons by professional vocalist Steve Glazer. It is designed with beginners in mind and walks students step by step through foundational skills.

What it offers:

3 hours 8 minutes of on-demand video, organized into 8 sections and 57 lectures.
Lifetime access, on mobile and TV platforms, plus a certificate of completion.
Content covers vocal warm-ups, breath control, pitch work, and foundational technique.
Includes extra resources: over 30 downloadable MP3 exercises, a 26-page workbook, and a 66-page songwriting e-book.
Delivered as one lesson per day, six days a week, over eight weeks.
Accessible pricing—frequently discounted to $11.99 from $79.99, with a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Ideal For: Beginners seeking a structured, affordable, and well-packaged entry into singing.

One of the biggest advantages of Udemy courses is lifetime access. Once you purchase it, you can revisit the lessons anytime without worrying about a subscription. The teaching is structured, clear, and affordable, often discounted during Udemy sales.

Pros of Singing Simplified #1 course:

Beginner-friendly, step-by-step lessons.
One-time payment with lifetime access.
Clear demonstrations of core vocal techniques.

Cons of Singing Simplified #1 course:

No real-time pitch feedback—you must self-assess.
No built-in vocal range test or personalized song matching.
Limited interactivity: it’s a static course, not adaptive software.
Motivation depends on self-discipline, as there’s no gamification.

Singing Carrots – Overview

Singing Carrots is a vocal training platform used by over 300,000 singers, built around an AI vocal coach that listens to you sing in real time and adapts every session to your voice — planning exercises around your range, adjusting difficulty as you go, and remembering your progress between sessions. Beyond pitch, the coach also analyzes voice quality: airiness, ring, vibrato, and loudness.

It’s the only singing app with published outcome data: across 2,000+ singers, beginners improved their pitch accuracy by +16.5 percentage points in four weeks. Around the coach sit its free tools — the vocal range test, pitch accuracy test, and real-time pitch monitor — plus song search that matches songs to your measured range.

Unlike Udemy, Singing Carrots is subscription-based, with flexible monthly and annual plans. It runs on iPhone (App Store) and in any browser.

Key Differences

Learning style: SINGING SIMPLIFIED #1 is video-based; Singing Carrots is interactive and feedback-driven.
Feedback: SINGING SIMPLIFIED #1 relies on your ear; Singing Carrots shows exact pitch deviation in real time.
Personalization: Udemy lessons are one-size-fits-all; Singing Carrots calibrates every drill to your range.
Practice tools: Singing Carrots offers start-note/tempo control and custom MIDI, Udemy does not.
Repertoire: Udemy leaves song choice open; Singing Carrots suggests songs and keys that fit your voice.
Cost model: Udemy is a one-time purchase with lifetime access; Singing Carrots is subscription-based but includes constant updates and interactive tools.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose SINGING SIMPLIFIED #1 if you want:

A clear, structured video path with affordable lifetime access
Step-by-step lessons in a more traditional, instructor-led format
A budget-friendly way to begin singing basics

Choose Singing Carrots if you want:

Real-time interaction with an AI Vocal Coch, pitch feedback and accuracy stats.
Exercises that adapt to your unique range and level.
Range-matched repertoire, MIDI practice, and motivational gamification
A flexible, interactive toolkit for daily practice

👉 For many singers, the two pair well together: start with SINGING SIMPLIFIED #1 for its approachable video lessons, then use Singing Carrots to practice smarter with interactive feedback and song-based tools.